Comprehensive Vs Third-Party Car Insurance: A Clear Guide To Understanding Your Options


May 7, 2024
Team Pineapple

Part of having a car means signing up for the risk of potentially getting into an accident. For a lucky few, that day never comes; others aren’t so lucky. It’s not just a matter of your capability but how careful other motorists are and what terrain you’re travelling on.

So, the moral of the insurance story is that it’s better to have coverage and not need it than to need an active policy and not have it.

Want insurance but don’t know where to start?

An example of popular (see; basic) insurance policies include comprehensive coverage and third-party policies.  

Understanding Comprehensive Car Insurance



UK 🔊 /ˌkɒm.prɪˈhen.sɪv/ US 🔊 /ˌkɑːm.prəˈhen.sɪv/

  1. including or dealing with all or nearly all elements or aspects of something.

“a comprehensive list of sources”

As the name suggests, comprehensive car insurance protects your vehicle from collision and non-collision-related perils. 

Comprehensive car insurance provides a broader range of coverage.

This kind of policy means covering your vehicle against various risks, namely ‘acts of God’ like floods, hail, earthquakes, fires and other perils such as theft, malicious damage, third-party liability and collisions with animals.

The benefits are endless, but we don’t mind going in-depth for those who aren’t as creatively inclined and struggle with imagination.

If you live in an area that suffers from severe weather conditions, staggering crime rates (specifically carjacking), you drive on roads with a high incidence of animals crossing, or a tree branch randomly falls on your car and shatters the windscreen, comprehensive cover can give you peace of mind.

However, the grass isn’t always greener because comprehensive coverage can come at a steep cost. 

Monthly premiums are typically higher than those for basic insurance policies. And if your car’s value is on the lower side, you might find that cost outweighs what you could recover from a claim.

Additionally, you’re subject to paying an excess fee before your insurance provider pays out your claim. Meaning you still have to cover a portion of the out-of-pocket costs.

Understanding Third-Party Car Insurance 




UK 🔊 /ˌthuhd paa·tee/ US 🔊 /ˌthurd paar·tee/

  1. a person or group besides the two primarily involved in a situation, especially a dispute.

“the involvement of a third party as an independent valuer”

While you might want all you can get from an insurance policy, you may find yourself in a tight spot financially, making this next to impossible.

Or is it?

Third-party insurance coverage is the answer to your predicament. 

Third-party coverage, also called third-party liability, is all about how you affect other motorists on the road. This insurance policy covers the damages or injuries you cause to others or their property while driving.

It's called ‘third-party’ because it deals with the third party involved in an accident – the person(s) you harm or whose property you might damage, rather than yourself or your vehicle.

Third-party coverage is a dream in scenarios where your main and only concern is covering the damages or injuries you might cause to others. It’s an excellent option if your car is an older model with a significantly decreased value or you use it infrequently.

However, like all good things, it has its limitations.

While it covers the costs for damages to others, it doesn’t cover damages to your vehicle or injuries sustained in an accident.  

Additionally, it won’t cover you for theft, malicious damage, or damage due to natural disasters. 

You may be saddled with significant repair or replacement costs if disaster strikes, creating potential financial distress.

But, the limited coverage isn’t all bad news; this allows the coverage to go for affordable premium prices, making it the more economically friendly option.


Comparison of Comprehensive and Third-Party Insurance

Understanding the differences can help you make an informed decision best suiting your needs, risk tolerance and financial situation. Let’s look at the differences between comprehensive and third-party car insurance.


As previously mentioned, third-party insurance typically costs less than comprehensive insurance. 

Third-party insurance tends to be cheaper because it offers more basic coverage, dealing mainly with liabilities to other parties in the event of an accident that you cause. 

With comprehensive coverage, you receive a broader range of coverage, and your car’s included in various potential risks. Coverage isn’t limited to third-party liability but includes weather-related damage, theft, and even roadside assistance in some policies.  

The price difference reflects the level of coverage provided.

Either that or the nature of the company – insurance providers like Naked and Pineapple are able to offer lower comprehensive premiums because they're digitally based.


Comprehensive coverage offers complete protection between the two, covering everything third-party insurance doesn’t.

It covers third-party insurance, offers additional benefits, and manages damage from accidents, theft, malicious damage, and even natural disasters.

On the other hand, a third-party policy only gives basic liability coverage to other people or their property. It won't cover damages to your vehicle or if your car is stolen.

Peace of Mind

If your biggest concern is how your driving habit could affect other motorists and the general public, then third-party insurance is right up your alley. 

But if you want to know that you're covered for a broader range of incidents, including those involving your vehicle, comprehensive insurance would be the better choice. 

The broader spectrum of coverage means greater peace of mind for you.

Satisfying Your Needs

Each coverage option has pros and cons; strictly speaking, there’s no wrong or right policy.

The choice will come down to your personal needs.

The decision of which coverage to take, comprehensive or third-party insurance, ultimately depends on your needs and circumstances.

To aid your decision-making journey, it’d help to consider the following:

  • The value of your car.
  • How frequently do you use it?
  • Your (financial) ability to replace or repair it.
  • Where do you keep the vehicle parked?
  • Your general risk tolerance.

The general rule of thumb is comprehensive insurance might be worth the higher premiums for those with a new or high-value car, people who park on the street in an area with high crime rates or individuals who simply want the assurance of all-encompassing protection. 

However, suppose you have an older car with low replacement value, park in a secure location, or don’t mind risking out-of-pocket costs for potential vehicle repairs or replacement. 

In that case, you might opt for third-party insurance.

Considering the potential financial implications when weighing comprehensive and third-party insurance costs and benefits is vital. 

Comprehensive insurance may have higher premiums, but it offers broader protection, reducing the risk of unexpected expenses that can disrupt your financial well-being. 

On the other hand, third-party insurance is more affordable but leaves you financially exposed if damage occurs to your vehicle.

After all, insurance is primarily about ensuring you're financially protected against unforeseen losses.


The right coverage doesn’t actually exist; instead, it comes down to which policy option is right for you and your car.

Your circumstances and budget should influence the decision between comprehensive versus third-party coverage, the value and age of your car, your risk tolerance, and your driving habits.

Comprehensive coverage might not be worth it for a car that’s been around the block more than a few times.

That, or if you're in a bit of a financial pinch. 

In that case, third-party insurance can provide you with the necessary coverage at a decidedly lower cost. 

However, the main thing to remember is that by choosing a lesser level of coverage, you're assuming more risk, as any damage to your vehicle would be out-of-pocket in the case of an accident where you are at fault.

But, if you’re riding around in the hottest, latest model, naturally, you’ll want to protect your investment.  

Additionally, if you live where carjacking, vandalism, or severe weather conditions are common, comprehensive insurance might be worth the higher premium price tag.

Not only does it ensure coverage for numerous incidents, but it also provides peace of mind and financial protection. 

To make what could be a long story short, what we’re trying to get across is this:

There's no one-size-fits-all answer. 

Instead, you’ll find the correct answer after taking a moment to carefully assess your needs and circumstances and possibly consult an insurance advisor to ensure you're making the best decision. Also, consider consulting comparison websites like Hippo to aid you in your insurance journey.

If you take nothing else from this piece, we hope you at least walk away with the knowledge of how essential car insurance is.

Basically, this is our not-so-subtle way of reminding you to take a moment to review your current car insurance policy. 

Are you fully covered in the event of an unexpected incident, or is there room for improvement?

After all, it's not just about having insurance – it's about having the right insurance for your specific needs. 

And where better to look for the perfect cover than with Pineapple? 

We offer fully comprehensive coverage that’ll help protect your vehicle should the unthinkable happen.

With recent happenings (snow in Gauteng, an explosion in Johannesburg and alarming crime rates), anything is possible.

Unlike the previously mentioned events, you at least have a say in what happens to your car.

So, don’t leave your car’s safety to chance or a higher being; get a quote with Pineapple today and enjoy the endless benefits of car insurance.

From affordable premiums starting at a low *R19-ish to awe-inspiring benefits that’ll give you so much peace of mind, a Buddhist monk would be jealous, Pineapple has it all.

Click this link to start your comprehensive insurance journey → CLICK (you know you wanna!)

The information provided above is for informational purposes only; you should not construe any such information as legal or financial advice.

Pineapple (FSP 48650) is underwritten by Old Mutual Insure, a licensed FSP and non-life insurer. T&Cs apply. Premium is risk profile dependent.

Team Pineapple

Team Pineapple comprises our company’s top talents, who are dedicated to creating clear, high-quality content on essential vehicle insurance topics. This diverse group, including actuaries, accountants, data scientists, and insurance professionals across South Africa, collaborates to produce enlightening and empowering articles.

Each piece is thoroughly researched, factually accurate, and rigorously reviewed to ensure quality.

*We say they’re the finest because we want them to keep writing for us!

Get an Obligation-free Car Insurance Quote Online From Pineapple

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.


Please Note: The information provided above is for informational purposes only; you should not construe any such information as legal or financial advice.

Give us a follow

We post a lot of nonsense. Some of it’s even about insurance. Give us a follow. There’s a 43% chance you might actually enjoy yourself.